The double-height living room with exposed brick, wood-burning fireplace and tall arched windows at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village

72 Horatio Street #1S Sold for $4.2M by Tom Postilio and Mickey Conlon

A 17-foot-ceilinged duplex loft inside a 1907 Romanesque Revival former stable on one of the West Village's tree-lined blocks has sold through Compass.

Listing: Tom Postilio · Mickey Conlon · Jennifer Rahilly — Compass

$4,225,000 · Closed October 28, 2026 · prewar duplex loft · 17-foot ceilings · exposed brick · wood-burning fireplace · Garland range · primary suite with walk-in closet · built-out mezzanine · 1907 Romanesque Revival former stable, eight-residence elevator co-op · West Village

Tom Postilio and Mickey Conlon of Compass, with Jennifer Rahilly, have sold 72 Horatio Street #1S in the West Village for $4,225,000. The sale closed on October 28, 2026. Postilio and Conlon are among Manhattan's best-known residential brokers. They're credited with nearly $3 billion in sales, The Wall Street Journal has named them among the top brokers in the United States, and they became familiar to television audiences in more than 70 countries on HGTV's Selling New York.

Apartment 1S is a prewar duplex inside 72 Horatio Street, built in 1907 as a Romanesque Revival stable and now a boutique, pet-friendly elevator co-op with just eight residences. Ceilings rise 17 feet over exposed brick walls and an open living room with a wood-burning fireplace. The main level also holds a dining area and a kitchen with professional-grade appliances, including a Garland range. The primary suite has a walk-in closet and its own bath.

Above, a built-out mezzanine overlooks the living room and gives room for an office, den or studio, with open-to-below sightlines carrying light through both levels. The block sits a short walk from the Whitney Museum, the High Line and Hudson River Park. With this sale, Postilio, Conlon and Rahilly have placed one of the West Village's converted-stable lofts with its next owner.

The living room toward the mezzanine and kitchen at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 2 of 13

The living room seating around the fireplace at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 3 of 13

The fireplace wall under the 17-foot ceiling at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 4 of 13

The open plan beneath the built-out mezzanine at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 5 of 13

The dining area at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 6 of 13

The kitchen at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 7 of 13

The primary bedroom with exposed brick at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 8 of 13

A bath with glass shower at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 9 of 13

The mezzanine bedroom and stair at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 10 of 13

A bath with tub at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 11 of 13

The stair up to the mezzanine at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 12 of 13

72 Horatio Street, the 1907 Romanesque Revival former stable at 72 Horatio Street #1S, West Village — photo 13 of 13

Closed sale. $2M+ in live markets only. Listing agents named as published. Source: sold record via Compass. Photos: Compass. Luxury Price Drops is not a brokerage.

72 Horatio Street #1S Sold for $4.2M by Tom Postilio and Mickey Conlon

US Guides

New York Guides

Reports

Markets

Company

72 Horatio Street #1S Sold for $4.2M by Tom Postilio and Mickey Conlon

Get Weekly Insights

US Guides

New York Guides

Reports

Markets

Company